category: literaturenote citekey: gurnellurbanriversurveymanual2007 title: Urban River Survey Manual authors: "Gurnell, Angela; Shuker, Lucy; Wharton, Geraldene" year: 2007 date: 2007-00-00 2007 publication: "Centre for Environmental Assessment, Management & Policy (kcl. ac. uk/ceamp)" zotero_key: QCDAD6XD zotero_storage: BE9UK6EU collections: magistritöö / kohalikud teed folder: 001_artiklid firstAuthor: "Gurnell, Angela"
Angela Gurnell, Lucy Shuker, Geraldene Wharton
1
The Urban River Survey (URS) was originally developed as part of the PhD thesis of Dr Angela Boitsidis (nee Davenport) (University of Birmingham 2001) under the supervision of Professor Angela Gurnell.
In 2003 the URS method and manual were modified by Angela Boitsidis and Angela Gurnell as part of the SMURF project (LIFE02 ENV/UK/000144).
The present (2016) version of the manual is a complete revision undertaken mainly by Angela Gurnell and Lucy Shuker under funding from Queen Mary, University of London and a ESRC-NERC funded research studentship awarded to Lucy Shuker with some additional contributions from Geraldene Wharton.
Any comments on lack of clarity or suggestions for improvements should be directed to a.m.gurnell@qmul.ac.uk
PLEASE NOTE THAT THE SURVEY METHOD IS BASED ON THE ENVIRONMENT AGENCY'S RIVER HABITAT SURVEY AND SO THIS MANUAL IS BEST USED IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE RHS MANUAL.
We thank the Environment Agency for permission to reproduce some diagrams from the River Habitat Survey in Britain and Ireland, Field Survey Guidance Manual, 2003 version.
We also thank Ruth Hanniffy of the Environment Agency for her collaboration in compiling this manual.
Cover photograph: Lucy Shuker
| SECTION 1: | Introduction to the Urban River Survey | 4 |
|---|---|---|
| SECTION 2: | Survey details | 5 |
| SECTION 3: | Site Information | 5 |
| SECTION 4: | URS Stretch Engineering | 6 |
| SECTION 5: | Channel Dimensions | 7 |
| SECTION 6: | Spot-check Measurements | 8 |
| SECTION 7: | Cumulative Measurements | 14 |
| APPENDIX A: | Urban River Survey Forms | 22 |
| APPENDIX B: | Urban River Survey Codes | 27 |
| APPENDIX C: | Engineering Descriptions and Photographs | 31 |
| APPENDIX D: | Seven Non-native 'Nuisance' Plant Species | 39 |
| APPENDIX E: Health and Safety | 43 |
This manual provides a modification of the RHS methodology which is specifically designed for urban rivers – the Urban River Survey (URS).
NNSS Be Plantwise : (http://www.nonnativespecies.org//beplantwise/index.cfm) and Check, Clean, Dry (http://www.nonnativespecies.org//checkcleandry/index.cfm)
three pages of summary definitions of the measurement codes (Appendix B) needed to complete the four page form. Where similar data to the RHS are being collected, the RHS definitions have been retained.
2.1 Enter the WFD water body ID (if known), the river name given on 1:50,000 scale maps, or more detailed scale if available. Unnamed headwater tributaries should be categorised as such, but refer to the named mainstream watercourse (e.g. tributary of River Quaggy). For the stretch name/number, surveyors should enter their own unique reference number/name as appropriate for the site. Also enter the date and time of the survey, and the name of the surveyor.
3.1 Stretch length: For the purpose of URS, stretches of river between 300m (minimum) and 500m in length are located in the field following identification of the limits of a single engineering type. The stretch length to the nearest 50m is determined by the surveyor (paces) and completed at the end of the survey when the actual length of the stretch has been estimated. The GPS readings (or estimates of the NGR) at the upstream and downstream end of the stretch also aid estimation of the stretch length. Wherever possible, the stretch length should be 500m.
4.1 The engineering type is representative of the surveyed stretch and is derived from a combination of the predominant planform, cross profile and level of reinforcement of
Table 1: Planform, Cross profile and Reinforcement Types and Codes
| Planform | Cross-Profile | Level of Reinforcement |
|---|---|---|
| Engineered Straight, ST (engineered to a straight planform) |
Enlarged, EN (cross section made substantially wider and/or deeper than a naturally adjusted channel would be at the same site) |
No reinforcement, NONE |
| Engineered Sinuous, ME (engineered to a sinuous planform) |
Two-stage, TS (cross section includes a flood channel with an inset smaller channel to accommodate non-flood flows) |
Bed reinforced, BED |
| Recovering, RC (engineered straight or sinuous but showing significant planform readjustment induced by fluvial processes) |
Resectioned, RS (cross section reshaped to a more efficient trapezoidal form) |
One Bank reinforced, ONE |
| Semi-natural, SN (no obvious sign of engineering of the planform) |
Cleaned, CL (flow resistance reduced through removal of roughness elements such as trees and shrubs and minor morphological irregularities) |
Bed and one bank reinforced, BEDONE |
| Restored, RE (cross profile form designed as part of a restoration scheme) |
Both banks reinforced, TWO | |
| Semi-natural, SN (cross profile form shows no obvious signs of engineered modification / has completely recovered from historical engineering) |
Full reinforcement, FULL |
Recording of the channel dimensions should be undertaken once in the surveyed stretch, and should be located at a riffle if one is present, or at a suitable shallow section of the river. Measurement accuracy is improved by using a ranging pole or other method of measurement. Channel dimension measurements are taken according to the RHS methodology as shown in Figure 1 below. Sometimes the river bed will be inaccessible or the water will be too deep or dangerous to measure directly. In these cases visually estimate the water depth if possible.
Figure 1: Channel dimensions (source: RHS 2003 manual)
6.1 NOTE: Many of the spot-check measurements coincide with those collected during RHS surveys. Summary definitions are provided here for convenience, but more detail can be obtained from the RHS handbook. 10 spot-check measurements are taken at equally spaced distances (e.g. every 50m for a 500m stretch). The spot check measurements are usually taken from the bank. The location of each spot check should be recorded using a GPS. Some of the measurements taken at each spot-check differ somewhat from the RHS manual but the general layout of the spot check measurements corresponds the RHS methodology as shown in the diagram below. Sweep up (SW) measurements differ from the RHS methodology. Any other feature seen throughout the reach that has not been recorded previously in the spot-checks is recorded in the sweep up column. (e.g. rarer macrophyte types such as SLL or RFL).
Figure 2: Dimensions for spot checks (source: RHS 2003 manual)
types are concrete (CC – cemented reinforcement providing a solid reinforcement with no gaps), concrete and brick (CB – comprised of blocks of bricks and mortar separated above, below or laterally by concreted areas), brick / laid stone (BR – areas of brick or stone held together by mortar to produce a solid wall or bank facing), builders waste (BW – loose hard core tipped at the bank toe or across much/all of the bank face); sheet piling (SP – interlocking steel sheets, including corrugated iron, protecting the bank face), wood piling (WP – vertical or horizontal wood planks protecting the bank face – often confined to the bank toe), rip-rap (RR – boulders: normally quarried, roughly square stones, often similar size, purposely tipped or laid along the bankface and often confined to the bank toe - includes un-cemented blockstone and boulders compacted into the bank with soil between), gabions (GA – stones in wire baskets), planted reeds (RE – only record when obviously, from regular spacing along bank toe, deliberately planted), willow spiling / faggot bundles (WS – cut stakes of willow driven into the bank toe or face, often linked by woven willow to create a living fence that roots into the bank / bundles of sticks or twigs), biotex / coir (BC – any woven fabric spread across the bank face to protect the underlying bank materials from erosion), washed out (WO - bank protection materials that have been eroded or have collapsed into the channel so that they no longer protect the banks).
6.2.3 Marginal and Bank Features (code check list provided in Appendix B): eroding cliff (EC – Bank face profile is predominantly vertical, near vertical, or undercut, with a minimum height of 0.5m and largely bare of vegetation (<50% cover of mosses, ferns, other vegetation)), stable cliff (SC – similar to eroding cliff but with higher vegetation cover (>50%), and no obvious signs of erosion), unvegetated point bar (PB – unconsolidated river bed material transported from upstream and deposited at the bank toe in a distinctive bar feature on the inside of river bends. Point bars are exposed at low flow and are unvegetated if <50% of their surface has vegetation cover), vegetated point bar (VP – identical to PB but with >50% of surface covered by vegetation), unvegetated side bar (SB – as PB but found along channel margins at locations other than the inside of bends), vegetated side bar (VS – as SB but with >50% of surface covered by vegetation), natural berm (NB – are the vegetated features which result from stabilisation and extension of PB, VPB, SB, VS features over time. A key difference between a 'bar' and a 'natural berm' is the former is made up of similar material to the channel substrate and has a gradual slope into the water whereas the latter often has a distinct steep face at the water edge and includes a transition towards terrestrial plant species).
6.2.5 Flow (Patch) Type (code check list provided in Appendix B): Flow types are identified from patterns and flow directions on areas / patches of the water surface and sometimes the additional influence of particles on the river bed. The predominant flow type is recorded at each spot check. Free fall (FF - generally associated with water falls and artificial vertical structures - vertically-falling water separates from the 'back-wall' of the vertical structure), chute (CH – mainly associated with cascades - .curving flow with substantial water contact with the substrate), broken-standing wave (BW - mostly associated with rapids but occasionally with riffles – recognised by white-water tumbling waves with an appearance that water is trying to flow upstream), unbroken standing wave (UW – mostly associated with major riffles but can be found on rapids - 'babbling' water with a disturbed 'dragon-back' surface, which has upstream facing wavelets that have not broken. White water may occur as crest waves, but not as breaking waves), chaotic flow (CF - . a chaotic mixture of three or more of the BW, UW, CH, FF flow types with no predominant one obvious), rippled (RP – mostly associated with runs - no waves, flow direction generally downstream with disturbed rippled surface), upwelling (UP – water surface heaving as upwelling water breaks the surface, has the appearance of boiling water), smooth (SM – mostly associated with glides, smooth downstream movement of water), no perceptible flow
(NP usually associated with pools marginal deadwater areas and areas ponded behind obstructions such as weirs - no obvious downstream movement of water), dry (DR – dry channel).
6.2.6 Channel Features (code check list provided in Appendix B): Exposed bedrock (EB bedrock protruding above the water surface at low flow), exposed boulders (RO – boulders protruding above the water surface at low flow), vegetated rock (VR – exposed bedrock or boulders supporting established vegetation such as herbs, reeds, grasses, shrubs), unvegetated mid-channel bar (MB – accumulation of unconsolidated river bed material exposed above the water surface but surrounded by water at low flow with <50% area covered by vegetation), vegetated mid-channel bar (VB – as for MB but with >50% area covered by vegetation), island (MI – well vegetated midchannel sedimentary feature, colonised by mature vegetation usually including shrubs or trees, with island surface at same level as bank tops), trash (TR – rubbish such as shopping trolleys, traffic cones, loose bricks, etc.)
6.3.1 Land use (code check list provided in Appendix B): Land use within 5m of the bank top is recorded using the following, self-explanatory, codes: URBAN: Residential (Re): Commercial (Cm); Industrial (In); Mixed Industrial/Commercial (Ic); Transport infrastructure (roads, railways) (Tr); Foot Path (Fp); Sewage Treatment Works (Sw); Landfill/Refuse (Ld); Scrap / waste recycling yards (Sy); Derelict/brownfield/abandoned land (Dr);
AGRICULTURE: Cultivated cropland (Cr); Pasture (Pa); Orchard (Or); Closed feeding - Intensive (indoor) stock production (Fe); Allotments (Al);
WOODLAND: Coniferous woodland (Co); Deciduous and mixed woodland (Dd); Open woodland (with grassland) (Ow);
OPEN SPACE: Open parkland and community grassland (Op); Rough grassland or herbs (Rg); Formal parkland / gardens (Fm); Recreational land (playing fields) (Rc); Cemeteries / crematoria (Ce); Recreational land (playing fields) (Rc); Cemeteries/crematoria (Ce); Heathland (He); Scrub (e.g. brambles, gorse, rhododendron and other woody shrubs) (Sc);
WATER SPACE: Lake/pond (La); Reservoir (Rv); Canal (Ca); Reclaimed (flooded) quarry (Qu); Junction with tributary stream/river (Tb); Marina / working harbour (Ma);
WETLAND: Wetland (Wl); OTHER: Other (Ot – a record type).
6.3.1 Bank Face and Top Vegetation Structure: This is recorded as defined in the RHS Manual and illustrated in Figure 3.
Figure 3: Codes for bank face and bank top vegetation structure (source: RHS 2003 manual)
6.4.1 The channel vegetation types are the same as recorded in the RHS and percentage cover is recorded as either 1% (present) or to the nearest 5%. Brief definitions are: none (<1% vegetation cover, or none is visible), liverworts/mosses/lichens (includes submerged vegetation or in the splash zone), emergent broad-leaved herbs (broadleaved plants rooted on the river bed or at the water's edge with foliage above the water surface), emergent reeds/sedges/rushes/grasses/horsetails (narrow-leaved plants rooted on the river bed or at the water's edge with foliage above the water surface), floating-leaved (rooted) (plants rooted on the river bed but with either broad or linear floating leaves), free-floating (plants floating on, or just under, the water surface, and not rooted to the river bed), amphibious (plants rooted at the edge of the river, or on the bank, but shoots or leaves trail across the water), submerged broadleaved (rooted submerged plants with underwater leaves no more than three times longer than broad - some part of the plant, or some leaves, may reach the surface but the majority are submerged), submerged linear-leaved (rooted submerged plants with narrow, unbranched, laminar leaves that are either totally submerged or just have their tips or upper parts floating on the surface), submerged fine-leaved (rooted submerged plants with fine, branched, leaves), filamentous algae. Channel vegetation types
Cumulative measurements provide an overall assessment of the character of the surveyed stretch and are recorded with a variety of measurement scales to suit their importance in the urban context
7.1.1 Bank Profile. Bank profiles are recorded in three categories: natural / unmodified, artificial (reinforcement), artificial (bank profile). In each case there is a 'none' class to ensure that percentages (nearest 5%) relating to all classes within any of the three categories sum to 100% over the reach. It is also possible for banks sections to fall into more than one of the three categories. For example a bank might have a natural lower profile (e.g. undercut) but have a resectioned upper profile and also be reinforced in the upper part of the bank. Figure 4 illustrates the classes within each of the three categories (note – poached refers to heavy trampling by animals or humans).
Channel dynamics are assessed as a proportion (%) of the stretch length as none, negligible (<5%), local (5-20%), extensive (20-30%), very extensive (>30%):
One bank eroding (i.e. showing vertical, vertical + toe, or undercut bank profiles on one bank – section 7.1)
Opposite banks eroding (i.e. showing vertical, vertical + toe, or undercut bank profiles on both opposing banks – section 7.1).
Opposite banks depositing (i.e. showing vegetated bars or berms on both opposing banks – section 6.2.3).
Berms on one or both banks totalling more than 25% channel width (one bank or both opposing banks with berm > 25% channel width - berm defined in section 6.2.3).
Channel dynamic features are assessed on an absent, present (<33% stretch affected), extensive (>33% stretch affected) scale relative to the stretch length or the extent of the features (e.g. bridge piers) that are involved.
Buried soil within bank profile (relatively organic-rich layers are present within the bank profiles and are overlain by sediment with a distinctly lower organic content)
Burial of river bed with fine sediment (the river bed sediment is buried by a finer sediment layer – usually the burial of a gravel bed by sand or silt that can be assessed by pushing a probe into the fine sediment to assess whether there is a coarser layer underneath)
Burial of base of structures (structures such as bridge piers, jetties show distinct signs of burial, usually by fine sediment but coarser bed material can also be deposited by floods to raise the river bed)
Burial of base of established vegetation (usually best indicated by the clear burial of the base of tree trunks)
River channel narrow relative to bridge openings (indicated where bridges have several openings and the outer openings are becoming closed or partly-closed by the accumulation of sediment)
Bed sediment exposed within bank profile (sediments of similar size and texture to the bed material (e.g. gravel layers that are coarser than the upper bank profile) are exposed in the river banks above current bed level).
Trees with exposed roots or collapsing / leaning into the channel on both (opposing) banks (bankside trees are heavily undercut to expose their root structures and/or are collapsing and/or are leaning into channel)
Exposure of foundations of structures (e.g. foundations of bridge or jetty piers) Heavily compacted and armoured bed (the river bed sediments are strongly compacted (individual particles are not easily removed) and armoured (there is a distinctly coarser layer of particles at the bed surface than immediately underneath).
7.3.1 Artificial Features are recorded in the same way as for the RHS, and are illustrated in Figure 5 (page 17) according to type and impact. For bridges complete the number of each type (rail, road, foot/cycle, other).
Figure 5: Types of artificial features and their impact level (minor, intermediate, major) (source: RHS 2003 manual)
7.5.1 Habitat Features are discrete features that are recorded as a count for the entire stretch. Definitions of bedrock (BE) and rock/boulder (RO) are given in section 6.2.1. Definitions of island (MI), unvegetated mid-channel bar (MB), vegetated mid-channel bar (VM), unvegetated point bar (PB), vegetated point bar (VP), unvegetated side bar (SB), vegetated side bar (VS) are given in sections 6.2.3 and 6.2.6. Definitions of riffle (RI) and Pool (PO) are given in section 7.5.2. The remaining categories relate to organic matter or areas of still water. A discrete organic matter deposit (OM) is comprised of wood pieces less than 1m length and 10cm diameter, twigs, leaves, and smaller organic material and forms a distinct patch within the river channel. Wood debris (WD) is one or more pieces of wood greater than 1 m length and 10 cm diameter forming a discrete deposit. A wood jam (WJ) is similar to WD but extends across the entire channel. Marginal backwater (MBW), connected backwater (CBW), and disconnected backwater (DBW) are areas of imperceptible flow located in the positions shown in Figure 6.
Figure 6: Backwater types
7.5.2 Flow (habitat) types are recorded according to the percentage (nearest 5%) of the water area affected by each type. They represent areas of the channel predominantly affected the flow (patch) types described in 6.2.5. Brief definitions of each type are as follows: cascade (CC - Distinct series of 'stepped' flow features occurring over boulder substrate or bedrock outcrops), boil (BL – area of channel where discrete areas of the water surface heave as upwelling water breaks the surface), rapid (RP – area with water surface dominated by broken standing waves), riffle (RI – area of channel dominated by unbroken standing waves), run (RU – area of channel with no waves, flow direction generally downstream with disturbed rippled surface), glide (GL – area of channel dominated by smooth downstream movement of water), pool (PO – discrete area of imperceptible flow over a low area in the channel bed), marginal deadwater (MD – discrete area of imperceptible flow associated with marginal and connected backwaters, see figure 6), ponded (PR – area of slow to imperceptible flow upstream of a channel obstruction such as a weir).
Figure 7: Tree distribution categories (source: RHS 2003 manual)
7.6.3 Special Features are extremely rare in urban river corridors. They are fully described in the RHS manual but the following are brief summaries: Side channels are discrete additional channels to the main channel, separated from the latter by a vegetated area and they may be dry in periods of low-flow; fens are comprised of wetland vegetation, often growing over peat, where the water-table is at, or just below, the surface (water is derived from both rainfall and drainage of surrounding land); marsh / bogs are
comprised of vegetation growing on wet peat where the water table is at, or just below, the surface and the water source is primarily direct rainfall; carr is wet woodland comprised of riparian tree species such as willows and alders, usually with an understorey of wetland herbs, reeds and mosses; water meadows are floodplain meadows, primarily associated with chalk streams, and traditionally flooded via constructed feeder channels; floating mats / reed beds form a distinct floating 'ledge' or shelf of vegetation extending into the channel.
Not all of the types of engineering will be found on any one urban river. Following are descriptions and pictures of the most common types seen in the built environment:
2.3 Restored (RE): River cross section has been modified (engineered) to a profile with a more natural appearance, usually as part of a restoration scheme (Plate C7).
2.4 Resectioned (RS): River cross section has been modified to a smooth trapezoidal profile (usually to improve flood conveyance) but is not obviously enlarged (Plate C8)
2.5 Enlarged (EN): River cross section has been enlarged (over widened and/or over deepened), may be accompanied by resectioning or 'canalisation'. At normal/low flows, overwidened channels have very shallow water, often only occupying part of the channel. Over widened and/or over deepened channels. are especially obvious where concrete channels have been created (Plates C9 & C10).
2.6 Two-Stage (TS): Characteristic step appearance to the bank where the narrower bottom section contains the average to low river flows, and the widened upper section contains the flood flows. Three stage channels are not uncommon in urban channels and should be placed in this category (Plate C11).
The characteristic / predominant level of reinforcement along a URS reach is defined as one of six categories (none, bed only, one bank only, bed and one bank only, both banks only, both banks and bed). Predominant bank reinforcment is recorded where reinforcement to any vertical extent up the bank (full, upper bank or lower bank) characterises all or most of the bank length in the surveyed reach.
The most commonly found levels of reinforcement are ONE BANK (C12), TWO BANKS (C13), FULL (C14)
Plate C1: Semi-Natural Planform
Plate C2: Engineered-Sinuous Planform
Plate C3: Engineered-Straight Planform
Plate C4: Recovering Planform
Plate C5: Semi Natural / Recovered Cross Section
Plate C6: Cleaned Cross Section
Plate C7: Restored Cross Section
Plate C8: Resectioned Cross Section
Plate C9: Enlarged (Overwidened) Cross Section
Plate C10: Enlarged (over-deepened) Cross Section
Plate C11: Two-Stage Cross Section
Plate C12: One Bank Only Reinforced
Plate C13: Both Banks Reinforced
Plate C14: Fully Reinforced
Photographs on the following pages were either provided by Christopher Cockel or the Environment Agency
For more information on these seven species, see Environment Agency (2010) Managing Invasive Non-native Plants,downloadable from www.environmentagency.gov.uk